Home Map News/Blog Calendar Links
Beer Dictionary Indiana Brewing History
 


A Brief History of Brewing in East Central Indiana

Anderson, Cambridge City, Connersville, Fountain City, Muncie,
New Castle, Randolph County, Richmond, Shelbyville

Anderson

Doxey's Brewery

1865-1866


"About the year 1865, Charles T. Doxey and William Craycraft built a brewery on the lot now occupied by Matthias Colchen's saloon and residence on West Eighth street, long known by the old-timers of Anderson as the Craycraft property.

They operated this establishment for about one year, when in the month of May, 1866, it took fire in the night and was destroyed and never rebuilt. This was Anderson's first brewery, and although small it was a pioneer in its line. It was soon followed by the now extensive place owned by T. M. Norton which was in its primitive stage a small affair as compared with its present capacity." - Historical Sketches and Reminiscences of Madison County, Indiana - 1897

Norton & Sullivan
Norton & Crowley
1866 - 1882

T.M. Norton Brewing Company
1882 - 1939


(photo courtesy
Bruce Mobley)

Thomas M. Norton, born in 1835 in Ireland, moved with his family from Ireland at the age of 6 to Dayton, OH where he was raised. In the 1860s he worked for Louis Williams brewing ale in Union City, IN (see Randolph County).

1866 he moved to Anderson and started a brewery with Patrick Sullivan. In 1882 he separated from Sullivan and started brewing on his own in his own brewery. He died in 1908.

The 1868 Anderson Business Directory lists Norton & Sullivan as being near the CC&IC Railroad. The brewery was just past the jail from the railroad station at 106-114 N Central Ave. In 1893 they had a telephone installed with the phone number 1.

The Norton Family lived at 124 N. Main St.

At some point, Michael Crowley replaced Patrick Sullivan in the company name. It would seem Crowley married one of Norton's daughters and, since they are not noted in a city directory of 1891, left town before that date.


"Thomas M. Norton was a man noted for his good citizenship. He was a member of the first board of workers, trustees, in Anderson, serving on the board ten years. He was a member of the Ancient Order of Hibernians, and was an active member and liberal supporter of St. Mary's Catholic Church. He had gone back to his native land in 1896 on a pleasure tour, and soon after his return to this country turned over his business affairs to his sons and lived practically retired for more than ten years.
"Thomas M. Norton married at Piqua, Ohio, in 1861, Miss Catherine McCarthy. They had four children: Mrs. J. C. Kreuch, Mrs. M. J. Crowley, Martin C. and William J., all residents of Anderson." - Indiana and Indianans: A History of Aboriginal and Territorial Indiana and the Century of Statehood, Jacob P Dunn - 1919.

In 1897 they added a stone stock house to the brewery at a cost of $16,000. They also had a private ice plant. The brewery was located near the river at the foot of 6th St.


"The president of the Norton Brewing Company is Martin C. Norton; William J. Norton is secretary and treasurer; and Mrs. J. C. Kreuch is vice president. William J. Norton was born at Anderson April 9, 1869, and grew up in that city, attending the public schools and one year in high school. At the age of sixteen he started working for his father in the brewery, and has been in practically every department, acquiring both the technical and business training. The Norton Brewing Company is widely known all over Central Indiana for its high products, the " Gold Band" and "Special Brew" of bottled beers, besides the Norton draft beers. A modern brewing plant was constructed in 1910, and from seventy-five to eighty people find employment in the business." - Indiana and Indianans: A History of Aboriginal and Territorial Indiana and the Century of Statehood, Jacob P Dunn - 1919.

Martin C. Norton was the President of the brewery but in 1913 he moved to become the manager of Berghoff Brewing in Fort Wayne. Mark Norton then seems to have then taken over the brewery. He participated in Democratic politics in Madison County.

Just before prohibition T.M. Norton produced 25,000 bbls per year. Brands included Norton's, Old Pal, and Gold Band.


"A liquor plot in which it is alleged that beer made In Anderson was marketed In Cincinnati, Hamilton and others In Ohio through a series of agencies is believed to have been uncovered by Federal officers under the direction of Bert Morgan, Indiana prohibition officer, here early today.

Prohibition Enforcement Officer Morgan, a squad of six of his operatives, Sheriff Daniels and the local police surrounded the Norton brewing plant here last night. About 1 o'clock this morning the officers watched two large auto trucks loaded with barrels at the loading platform of the Norton brewery, which is located in the heart of Anderson and is adjacent to the jail.

After the trucks had been loaded, Morgan and Federal officers accosted the drivers, placing them under arrest. The driver of the two trucks gave their names as William Schramm, agent for Indianapolis Brewing Company at Hamilton, Ohio and Frank Houser.

The officers confiscated forty half barrels and nine barrels of beer which were found on the trucks. The beer, which Federal officers say is believed to test 5 per cent, was confiscated by the officers as evidence and placed under lock and key In the basement of the county jail here." - Indianapolis Star, June 18, 1923


U. S. DRY OFFICERS TAKE INVENTORY OF BREWERY

"ANDERSON. Ind. State Prohibition Officers George Winkler and Seth Ward of Indianapolis and William Ray arrived here this afternoon and started taking an Inventory of the property of the Norton Brewery. Following completion of the Inventory a return will be made to United States Commissioner Howard S. Young. The Inventory marks seizure of the brewery by United States authorities. The Federal officers state that a warrant has been sworn out for the arrest of William Norton, owner of the Brewery" - Indianapolis Star, June 26, 1923

William J. Norton was sentenced to a prison in Atlanta for "violation of the liquor law".

The building became Ralston Purina feeds in the 1950s. They also produced ice for retail sale.

A Brewers Union was organized in Anderson in 1891.

Cambridge City

Cleophas Straub

???? - ~1885

"According to an older resident, Straub's beer 'didn't take and never became very popular.' " Unknown Cambridge City newspaper.
Henry Ingermann

W. H. Ingermann

John M. Ingermann

1820 - ~1905

The 1868 Business Directory for Indiana lists a brewery owned by Henry Ingermann, an immigrant from Germany. It was located at the corner of Vandalia Ave. and Delaware St. in the town of Vandalia (now merged into Cambridge City). His son George soon joined the company as did brewer Cleophas Straub who had previously owned another brewery until about 1885. Later a nephew, another Henry Ingermann, Charles Swim, and Tom Enyart owned the brewery.

The beer was sold in pints and quarts with rubber stoppers as "Ingermann's Ale" with XXX or XXXX indicia. It brewed about 500 bbls per year.

There is a reference to 40,000 shares of capital stock registered with the state by Ingermann Brewing Company on Oct 26, 1906. This might have been a restart of the company that did not succeed.

See Ingermann.com for more pictures and information.

An Ingermann descendant, Chris Ingermann is now and active and award-winning homebrewer.

Connersville

John Uhl

1857 - 1859

John Uhl purchased interest in a brewery in Connersville in 1857. He was connected to that business for 2 years. He then opened a cooperage that employed 16 men and was sold to a consortium of people in the pork-packing business in 1865.
Valentine Billan

???? - ~1885

The Register of United States Breweries 1876-1976 lists a brewery in Connersville owned by Valentine Billan. It closed about 1885.


"Martin Gruenewald was born in Darmstad, Germany, October 12. 1839. He came to America at the age of twenty-one with four dollars in his pocket, and went to Chilicothe, Ohio. In 1861 he moved to Connersville, Indiana, ...  Martin and Christiana Dick were married in 1866, and moved to Anderson in 1869. ... Mr. Gruenewald had managed a brewery in Connersville, and wished to open one in Anderson. When he could not obtain the proper permits, he opened a Billiard Parlor and Sampling Room. He became one of Anderson's most successful businessmen and landowners."  - The Gruenewald Historic House, 626 Main St. Anderson, IN

Fountain City

A brewery was started in New Garden Township in 1825


"A brewery, started there in 1825, was abandoned on account of the hostility of the inhabitants towards it. In the year 1828, William Way started another, but it soon succumbed to the pressure of public opinion. In 1829 four saloons were present in Fountain City; in 1830, a temperance society was organized to resist their influence; a debate was opened on the question between the liquor men and the anti-liquor men; it occurred in public from 2 o'clock p. m. until after midnight. The temperance debaters were Dr. H. H. Way, Able Lomax, and Willis Davis. The representatives of the whiskey faction were John Huff, E. Lee, and Joseph Lomax. The debate is said to have been won by the anti-liquor men. This locality succeeded in getting rid of its saloons and is now free from their baneful influence.  - Memoirs of Wayne County and the City of Richmond, 1912.

The History of Wayne County (1884) says about New Garden Township: "Edward Mason started a brewery early."

Memoirs of Wayne County and the City of Richmond, 1912, says "A brewery was started very early by Edward Mason."

This brewery was in the town of Newport in Wayne County. This town was renamed Fountain City in 1879.

Muncie

After the 1850s there seemingly was a brewery on Ohio Ave. near the cemetery.
Fay & Garst
???? - ~1875

A. J. Garst
~1875 - 1887

Bartlett & Garst
1887 - 1890

The Register of United States Breweries 1876-1976 lists a brewery owned by Fay & Garst that became A.J. Garst in about 1875 and became Bartlett & Garst in 1887. This brewery closed in 1890.

Strangely, the 1876/1877 Emerson Directory of Muncie lists Albert J. Garst as a butcher on S. Walnut. The same source says there was a brewery on S. Illinois Ave.

Muncie Brewing Company

1902 - 1912 or later

(photo courtesy Bruce Mobley)

John Birkenstock rebuilt a brewery in Allentown, PA, in 1891 but it didn't work out too well. In 1897 he and Fred Horlacher built another brewery. Birkenstock sold his interests and moved to Muncie in 1902, opening another brewery. Some references say this was in 1906.

Birkenstock was an immigrant from Hessen Darmstadt, Germany, born in 1845. His wife, Elizabeth Scholl was born in 1868 in the William Penn house in Philadelphia - the first house in America made of English brick.

The brewery building was designed and built by a Philadelphia firm. It was at the northwest corner of Hoyt and Willard Streets.

A major stockholder and city scion, John Griesheimer, went personally bankrupt in 1907. This did not affect the brewery operations.

New Castle

Laboyteaux   

1865 - ????

A very obscure brewery. There is reference that the company was started in 1865 on Hagerstown Pike, just east of New Castle.

There was a Laboyteaux family from New Castle who had several members serving in the Civil War. Thomas Laboyteaux was killed, possibly in the Sultana sinking, while returning from the South.

The bottle reads "J. F. Laboyteaux".

It has been reported that a bottle similar to the one shown here was found in the 1970s/80s in a canal in Lafayette, Indiana.

(photo courtesy Bruce Mobley)

The Register of United States Breweries 1876-1976 lists a brewery in New Castle owned by Patrick Leonard. It never made more than 60 bbls per year. Closed before 1875.

Randolph County

Louis Williams and Thomas M Norton (see Anderson above) brewed ale in Union City in the 1860s.

Conrad Meyer (or Meier), an immigrant from Bayreuth, Bavaria, moved to Winchester in 1873 and operated a bakery and a brewery until 1880. The brewery had a maximum capacity of 355 bbls.


The Register of United States Breweries 1876-1976 lists a brewery in Ridgeville owned by J. K. Hammerle. It had production of 330 bbls and closed before 1875.

Joseph Lay and his son, Samuel Lay moved their Joseph Lay Company making brooms from New York state to Ridgeville, IN in 1886. "They took over an abandoned brewery (which looked something like an Eastern Orthodox church) and the buildings of a defunct college." according to company records.

Richmond
(also see Wayne County)

Boswell

1816 - 1831

Ezra Boswell was born in England in 1788 and was a brewer there before emigrating to North Carolina and then Richmond in 1816.


"The first brewery in Richmond was commenced by Ezra Boswell about the time the town was incorporated (Richmond was incorporated in 1817 - ed). Of the quality of the beer we have now no opportunity of forming a judgment, but it is said that some of the Councilmen of that day—who, of course, served their fellow-citizens gratuitously—one day sent to Ezra for some of his brewing, and we presume, they quaffed it until they were satisfied, but, like all men in place, they, by this simple act, subjected themselves to the tongue of slander. By the citizens, who took it upon themselves to watch over the pecuniary interests of the place, a rumor was set afloat that the Councilmen were drinking beer at the expense of the corporation.

"The price of beer, sold at taverns, was in that day fixed by the court at 12½ cents a quart, while the same authority rated whiskey, per half-pint, at 12½ cents, the same quantity of common brandy, at 18¾ cents, and cognac, rum, and wine were to be sold at 37½ cents by the half pint. The care of the Court in this particular is further evinced by their allowing George Hunt, clerk, a certain sum for the purchase of whisky, during the sale of lots in Salisbury." - Reminiscences of the History of Richmond, John Plummer, 1857.


"The first brewery in Richmond went into operation sometime between 1816 and 1818. Ezra Boswell, who came to Richmond in 1816, was the proprietor. Young's History of Wayne County has the following to say about Boswell and the brewery:

"His shop from which he supplied the citizens of the town and country with beer and cakes was on Front street (Fort Wayne avenue) north of Main. It was much frequented by the citizens and the country people who came to town on business, beer then being deemed a wholesale beverage. Boswell was a respectable man, and a member of the first Board of Trustees of the town, elected after its incorporation" - Palladium Item & Sun Telegram, City Edition, Nov 15, 1945

Boswell, a Quaker, continued the brewery until his death in 1831. He was elected the first clerk of the Richmond city council.


"Two Englishmen, direct from London, began the establishment of a brewery in 1827, which the Public Ledger predicted would be successful. The editor also thought that 'the wholesome beverage should take the place of the burning whisky which is now so common.' This brewery was at the old Cushman distillery." - History of Wayne County, Indiana, 1884

Christian Buhl
Main Street Brewery
1832 - 1869

Minck Brewing Company
1869 - 1912?

(photo courtesy
Bruce Mobley)

The brewhouse was just east of the Main Street bridge over the Whitewater River, near the Wayne County courthouse.


"Christian Buhl, direct from Germany, came to Richmond as early as 1830, established a brewery on Main street, west side of the town, near the National bridge. It was extensively patronized, not only by the citizens but by travelers and emigrants passing near it. At nearly every raising one or more kegs or buckets of Buhl's beer were drunk. The stream of small coin constantly flowing into his money drawer for a few years made him a comparatively rich man. He bought a large farm a mile and a half southwest of the town where he died a few years later. George, one of his sons, later resided on the farm." - Palladium Item & Sun Telegram, City Edition, Nov 15, 1945

Buhl first built the building as a tavern and later expanded to include a brewery.


"The main building of the present Main Street Brewery was started by Christian Buhl, who established a brewery in Richmond as early as 1830. In 1869 it was purchased at sheriff's sale by Emil Minck, its present proprietor. Mr. Minck has made several improvements and carries on quite an extensive business. His son, Emil Minck, Jr., is associated with him in the management of the establishment. - History of Wayne County, Indiana, 1884


"Emil Minck was born in Germany in 1832, and when fifteen years of age came to America with his parents and settled in Columbus, Ohio, where he learned the brewer's trade of Hosier & Co., and in 1869 came to Richmond, Ind., where he has since lived. In 1872 he purchased the brewery, of which he is still proprietor. It was erected in 1832 by Jacob Buhl and is one of the oldest establishments of the kind in Eastern Indiana. Mr. Minck, in 1883, enlarged the building, making it at present 40 x 60 feet, three stories high, with an ice-house 20 x 165 feet. He manufactures from 500 to 1,000 barrels of lager beer a year. It is the purest kind and is mostly consumed by private families." - History of Wayne County, Indiana, 1884

Officers of the Minck Brewing Company when brewing ended at Prohibition were Lewis E Iliff, president, and Adolph W Blickwedel, secretary (he also had a tavern in the area). At the maximum, their capacity was reportedly 4,000 bbls.

The building became an auto parts store and was razed in 1960. It was on the south side of Main St between First and Second.

Winterling & Paulus

~1868

The 1868 Business Directory for Indiana lists a lager brewery on Main Street owned by Winterling & Paulus.
Margaret Martischang

???? - ~1885

The Register of United States Breweries 1876-1976 lists a brewery owned by Margaret Martischang that closed about 1885. It had a capacity of under 500 bbls.
It is also thought that a tavern was opened in 1816 by Philip Harter. This was in a log building on lot #6 of S. Pearl St.


FOR SALE
THAT well-known TAVERN STAND, In the Town of Richmond, lately the occupation of Wm. H. Vaughan. A bargain will be given, and possession at any time that will suit the purchaser. Ephraim Lacey - Richmond Public Ledger, 1828.

Shelbyville

The Register of United States Breweries 1876-1976 lists a brewery in Shelbyville owned by Margaret Stephan. This closed before 1875 and at a peak made 95 bbls annually.

Copyright 2004, 2006, 2009, Bob Ostrander