A Brief History of Brewing in Indianapolis, Indiana

Indianapolis Brewing Company

Gack & Biser

P. Lieber Brewing Company

About 1868 - 1887


C. F. Schmidt Brewing Company

1850 - 1887


Casper Maus Brewery

1868 - 1887


Indianapolis Brewing Company

1887 - 1948


(photos courtesy
Bruce Mobley)

Peter Lieber was the private secretary to General Oliver Morton during the Civil War. He and brother Hermann bought the brewing firm of Gack & Biser renamed it the P. Lieber Brewing Company. The date of this purchase is quoted in some sources as being in the 1870s but the 1868 Indiana Business Directory lists "City Brewery, P Lieber & Co, 213 S. Pennsylvania" so it's safe to assume this firm started before then. Hermann sold his interest in 1880 to William Schrever.

Jacob Metzger, a German immigrant and father-in-law of Herman Lieber, had a bottling company in Indianapolis and bottled Metzger and Tafel brand beers made by the P. Lieber company in 1893. He also bottled Budweiser, Bass Ale, and Guinness Extra Stout.

Founded by John Schmidt, the C.F. Schmidt brewery was located at the south end of Alabama Street. "By the outbreak of the Civil War, Schmidt Brewery was producing a superior lager beer, and soon was supplying troops stationed in Indianapolis." - Nuvo, June 8, 2005.


"Mr. Bosenberg is sole agent for the justly celebrated C. F. Smith's (sic) Lager Beer, manufactured at Indianapolis, Indiana. The qualities for which this beer is most distinguished are its healthfulness, purity, brilliancy of color, richness of flavor &c, the result of excellent water, intelligent care of its brewers conjoined to the use of apparatus possessing all the best modern improvements made in this country or elsewhere, and to the superior quality and quantity of the ingredients used. No claims are made for this beer that cannot be substantiated." - Rochester Sentinel, Feb 29, 1888

Caspar Maus, an immigrant from the Alsace-Lorraine region of France, moved to Indianapolis to get away from pro-slavery interests during the Civil War. His older brother, Frank Maus Fauvre, was married to someone of the Schmidt brewery family.


These three brewing companies formed the basis of the Indianapolis Brewing Company in 1887.

Peter Lieber was the president of the new company. Albert Lieber, Peter Lieber's son was the first managing director. They both were Republicans but changed allegiance because of a temperance plank in the party's platform. Peter was very involved in Democratic politics and was the messenger who took Indiana's electoral votes to Congress one year. Peter was appointed Counsel to Duesseldorf in 1893 by President Grover Cleveland.

There evidently was a time when the three breweries had a working relationship before 1887. The Daily Herald of Delphos, Ohio, July 15, 1896, reported a fire in Lieber's brewery "on Madison" and said "Lieber's brewery is one of the three in this city controlled by the Indianapolis Brewing owned by an English syndicate."

The C. Maus plant was converted into a distillery in early 1900.


"Indianapolis is the Home of Gold Medal Beer Lieber's Special Bottled and Porter

The Great Plants of the Indianapolis Brewing Company, R Schmidt Branch, and P. Lieber have long been first among the show places of business enterprise of this and every year to thousands of visitors from far and as admirable examples of order and perfect sanitary conditions in the manufacture of malt. The up-to-date equipment of all that constitutes a modern brewery makes this company rank among the largest and best in the world.

The output is not only known over the United States but the bottled goods are exported to the West Indies and South America. It is entirely within the truth to say that no product sent out of our city carries the name of Indianapolis to as many people of this earth as do the labels placed upon products of this company.

Thirty million labels are annually used in the bottling department. The company has approximately 500 employees here.  210 head of horses and 9 automobiles are required in the work. Besides brewers there are employed wagon electrical steamfitters and machinists. Brewers in this country and at every international exhibition of importance.

The magnificent reputation of the large business enjoyed by the company was not built in a day. Its substantial foundations were laid over fifty years when three small breweries were founded by Peter Lieber, C. Schmidt and C. Maus. In 1889 these breweries were amalgamated into the present company. The company is one of the largest if not the largest taxpayer in Indianapolis or Marion County. A cordial invitation is extended to the public to inspect its plants at any time." - Ad in Indianapolis Star, Sept 7, 1914

John W. Schmidt died in Feb, 1914. He sold his interest in the brewing business in 1890 according to his obituary in the Indianapolis Star, Feb, 23, 1914.

They made Ozotonic and malt extract before and during prohibition.

C. F. Schmidt plant at McCarty and High Streets closed on May 27, 1920 after 70 years of brewing.

Reincorporated as Indiana Breweries, Inc. after prohibition (1933). Renamed back to Indianapolis Brewing Co in 1935.

A correspondent writes "My mother was going through an old box and discovered  numerous items from our family's history. Among these items are stock  certificates for 'Lieber Brewing Corporation'. They are dated January 1935.

The Indianapolis Encyclopedia reports that the IBC closed in the 1940s when the president, Lawrence Barden, went to jail for short-filling bottles.

Brands included Tafel, Circle City, Crown Select, Duesseldorfer, Lieber's Gold Medal Beer ("Tastes Right, Named Right"), Tonica, Burgomaster, Derby, and Progress Beer.

Located on the northwest corner of what is now New York and University Boulevard on the IUPUI campus.

They won a gold medal for their Duesseldorfer in Paris in 1900. There was a "magnificent industrial parade" when they returned with the medal. They also won the grand prize gold at the St. Louis World's Fair in 1904.

Kurt Vonnegut's grandfather was Albert Lieber. The recipe for a dark lager beer that Peter Lieber devised was brewed by Wyncoop Brewing, Denver, in 1996 to celebrate the new library there. It was called Kurt's Mile-High Malt. A "secret ingredient" of the brew was coffee.

The company put out a set of baseball trading cards in 1916.

In 1938 they appealed a case to the US Supreme Court to fight Michigan's beer importation laws. They lost. This case has been referenced many times including G. Heilman's bankruptcy and many cases about mail-order beer and wine sales.


Home of John William Schmidt,
president of the Indianapolis Brewing Company.
Built in 1890.


Coin minted for IBC's Gold Medal Beer.

   

  

Home Brewing Company

Home Brewing Company

By 1880 - 1920


(photo courtesy Bruce Mobley)

There are records of a Frank Prange being a stockholder in this company sometime after 1880 and a building being built for the company sometime after 1883.

Hermann Gaul designed the factory structure of Home Brewing Company at 38 Shelby St. as well as the Saint Mary Church at 317 N. New Jersey St.

August Hook, an immigrant from Viernhelm, Germany, was one of the organizers of HBC and was the president of Home Brewing Company until he died of pneumonia on Dec 10, 1909, aged 60. Before coming to Indianapolis, he was the brewmaster at the Lackmann Brewery in Cincinnati.


"Brewery Case Appeal Brief Declares Ouster Action Is Without Province.

The jurisdiction of the Marion Superior Court and the right of Attorney-General James Bingham to bring action in the case of the attorney general vs. the Home Brewing is denied in a brief filed in the Appellate Court yesterday by the plaintiff. The action would dissolve the Home Brewing Company on the grounds that it is monopolizing the beer trade to itself and that its operations violate the anti-trust law." - Indianapolis Star, Sept 21, 1910

Home Brewing did not make it through prohibition.

American Brewing Company (ABC)

American Brewing Company

Before 1897 - 1917


(photo courtesy Bruce Mobley)

Owner: Thomas Bowser

Joseph C. Schaf was president in 1910.

The brewery was located at Market and Missouri Streets.

Sponsored the Indianapolis ABC's Negro National League baseball team starting in 1905. Note that this was not the "brewery team" or owned by the brewery. In fact the brewery went out of business before the National Negro League was formed.

The ABC's were previously the Birmingham Giants and seem to have moved to Indiana in 1902. In 1914 they played in West Baden, IN. They won the Colored World Championship in 1916 and were in the Negro National League when it formed in 1920. The manager of the ABCs, Charles I. Taylor, bought an interest in the brewery but died in 1922. The team was disbanded in 1927. more info


"BLUE LABEL

The Claypool Hotel serves American Brewing Co. Beers in both cafe and buffet. Its delicious flavor commends it to those who know the is at the same time the most convincing proof of its purity and character." - Ad in the Indianapolis Star, March 28, 1915.

There is no record of the brewery after prohibition.


The Indianapolis ABCs at Washington Park in 1922.

Ajax Brewing Company

Capital City Brewing Co.

1905 - 1941

Capital City Brewing Co. 1905 - 1915
Citizens Brewing Co. 1915 - 1918
Richard Lieber Brewing Corp. 1934 - 1935
Lieber Brewing Corp. 1935 - 1937
Phoenix Brewing Corp. 1937 - 1938
Ajax Brewing Corp. 1938 - 1941

Brand names: Imperial, Duselager

Located at 1224 S. West St.

Charles Krauss was president of the Capital City Brewing Company in 1910.

Richard Lieber was born in Dusseldorf, a nephew of Peter and Hermann Lieber. He moved to Indianapolis to live with an uncle in 1891 and worked as a reporter on his father-in-law's Indiana Tribune until that newspaper was sold in 1907.

He was the director of the Indiana Department of Conservation until 1933 when he bought Citizens Brewing and made soft drinks. This expanded to beer after prohibition.

He is known as the father of the Indiana State Park system. He had traveled with Teddy Roosevelt and John Muir to the western to-be-parklands in California. He was also instrumental in contracting with Bruno Schmitz to build the Soldier's and Sailor's Monument in Indianapolis. Lieber State Park is named after him.

Others

"In 1834, William Werweg, a contractor for the National Road (now Washington Street) and John L. Young established the first brewery in Indianapolis." - Nuvo, Rita Kohn, June 8, 2005.

Here's a picture of a bottle of Frank Wrights Ale. Time of manufacture unknown but his brewery was listed in The 1868 Business Directory for Indiana. The brewery was on Blake Street near the river.

(photo courtesy Bruce Mobley)

The 1868 Business Directory for Indiana lists a brewery owned by John P Meikel at 297 W. Washington Street.

Albert Lieber (see Indianapolis Brewing above) was the president of the Schalk Brewery, Inc. in 1916. - source: One Thousand American Men of Mark of To-day, published in 1916

There is evidence of other pre-prohibition breweries or beer brands in Indianapolis including Trium, E.T. HollerIndiana, Tannenbock, Topaz, and Spatzel.

Modern-day Breweries

Indianapolis Brewing Company

1989 - 1997

Located in an industrial park on Post Road, north of 30th St. John Battles was the brewer.

Known familiarly as the Naptown Brewery.

Sold under brand names Duesseldorfer and Main Street.

They also produced "contract" beers for Pike Place in Oregon and O'Malleys for the Fort Wayne Brewing Company.

When the brewery closed, the facility was purchased by the Oaken Barrel Brewing Company of Greenwood, IN who used it until 2003.

  

Broad Ripple Brewing Company

1990 - Present

The first Indiana Brewpub of the late 1900's boom.

Founded by John Hill, an immigrant from Yorkshire, England.

The company was organized in two parts, the BRBC and the Broad Ripple Brewpub, since Indiana state law didn't yet allow for brewpubs.

The first brewer, Greg Emig, left in 1993 to found the Lafayette Brewing Co. The second brewer, Ted Miller founded the Brugge Brasserie in 2005 (below). The third brewer is Kevin Matalucci.

Alcatraz Brewing Company

1995 - Present

Brewpub. Part of the California Cafe chain which went bankrupt in 2003 and was sold to Tavistock Restraurants. Located at an entrance to the Circle Center Mall in downtown Indianapolis.

Circle V Brewing Company

1996 - 2001

Founded by Mark Vojnovich as a brewpub.

It closed the food operations on April 19, 1999 and tried to make it as a regional brewer.

Ram Restaurant & Brewery

1996 - Present

Brewpub. Part of the Big Horn chain out of Tacoma, WA. Built in a space on south Illinois St. previously used by a short-lived Planet Hollywood.

Rock Bottom Restaurant and Brewery

1996 - Present

2005 - Present

Brewpub. Part of the Rock Bottom chain out of Denver.

A second Rock Bottom was opened with its own brewery in 2005 near 86th St between Township Line Rd. and Michigan Rd.

Wildcat Brewing Company

1996 - 1998

An extract brewpub added to a Bombay Bicycle Club chain restaurant on Michigan Road near I-465 on Indianapolis' northwest side. Reviews of the beers were not good and it closed after about 2 years in business. The chain also tried this same formula with one of their restaurants in Clearwater, FL.

Glacier's End

1997 - 1999

Built inside an entrance to the Castleton Square Mall.

Some of the equipment ended up at the Cumberland brewpub in Louisville.

Hops

1998 - 1999?

One of the Hops chain out of Atlanta.

Brugge Brasserie

2005 - Present

Brewpub. Started by Ted Miller, formerly the brewer at the Broad Ripple Brewpub and located only 4 blocks away. Belgian beers are the specialty.

Notably, Abraham Benrubi, a Hollywood TV actor known for a roll in "ER" is a part-owner of the brewery.

Copyright 2004, 2006, Bob Ostrander